Slowtide

A brand-new home perched on a cliff outside Gregory Town, built around 180-degree Caribbean views rather than around it. Two king master suites and two lofts (one with a queen, one with two singles) sleep six across the house, all on gel-infused memory foam. A private stairway leads down to the water in front, while some of the island’s best surf breaks sit right behind the property — a rare pairing on Eleuthera.

Worth knowing: the walkway down to the stairs is steep, and the hosts advise real caution for anyone not used to it. A rental car is essentially required here — expect $85–100/day — since Eleuthera is 110 miles long and this stretch is a drive from most settlements, though restaurants like Unca Genes and Pittman’s Cove are just five minutes away. The hosts are notably responsive, with a full guidebook and nearly 60 reviews to back it up.