Every rental we guide

The rentals we'd actually book.

12 properties, vetted by the community and written up honestly — no pay-to-play, no sponsored placements.

New Providence

Nassau & Paradise Island

Nassau guide
Exclusive Ocean Villa, New Providence · Nassau
Oceanfront estate

New Providence · Nassau

Exclusive Ocean Villa

A 5-bedroom oceanfront villa in Nassau with 120 feet of private beach, an infinity pool, and a 90-foot dock. Built for groups who want total privacy.

5 BR · 6 BASleeps 10

$1680per night · est.

Explore listing
Ocean Paradise, Yamacraw Hill Road · Nassau
Private pool

Yamacraw Hill Road · Nassau

Ocean Paradise

A 3-bedroom oceanfront villa on Yamacraw Hill Road with a private pool and a coral reef 35 steps from the door, minutes from Atlantis.

3 BR · 2 BASleeps 10

$340per night · est.

Explore listing
Sunrise by the Sea, Treasure Cove · Nassau
Beachfront

Treasure Cove · Nassau

Sunrise by the Sea

A 4-bedroom home on the water at Nassau's quiet eastern tip, with kayaks and snorkel gear on hand and sunrise views right off the patio.

4 BR · 3.5 BASleeps 8

$515per night · est.

Explore listing

The Out Islands

Exuma

Exuma guide
Exuma On The Rocks, George Town · Great Exuma
Private peninsula

George Town · Exuma

Exuma On The Rocks

A 6,000-square-foot villa on its own private peninsula near George Town, with 180-degree ocean views from nearly every room and a dock built for a 35-foot boat.

4 BR · 5.5 BASleeps 8

$3880per night · est.

Explore listing
Thatch Bay Cottage, Little Exuma · Great Exuma
Secluded beach

Little Exuma · Exuma

Thatch Bay Cottage

A quiet three-bedroom cottage on a secluded Little Exuma beach, with wrap-around deck views, a backup generator, and Starlink for truly stress-free stays.

3 BR · 2 BASleeps 7

$780per night · est.

Explore listing

& Harbour Island

Eleuthera & Harbour Island

Eleuthera guide
Cornerwall House, Governor's Harbour · Eleuthera
Historic harbour views

Governor's Harbour · Eleuthera

Cornerwall House

A restored 1905 sea captain's home right on Governor's Harbour, Eleuthera, with sea-view balconies off every bedroom and a pool overlooking the water.

3 BR · 3.5 BASleeps 6

$741per night · est.

Explore listing
Slowtide, Gregory Town · North Eleuthera
Cliffside ocean views

Gregory Town · Eleuthera

Slowtide

A brand-new cliffside home near Gregory Town, Eleuthera, with 180-degree Caribbean views, surf right behind it, and steps down to the water out front.

2 BR · 2 BASleeps 6

$429per night · est.

Explore listing

Freeport & Lucaya

Grand Bahama

Grand Bahama guide
Bahama Reef Beach House, Fortune Beach · Grand Bahama
Beachfront

Fortune Beach · Grand Bahama

Bahama Reef Beach House

A 3-bedroom bungalow in a gated beachfront community on Grand Bahama, with a full-length deck over the sand and a shared pool and tennis court.

3 BR · 3 BASleeps 6

$415per night · est.

Explore listing
Frangipani House, Freeport · Grand Bahama
Rental car on site

Freeport · Grand Bahama

Frangipani House

A three-bedroom guest suite in Freeport, 200 meters from the beach, with an on-site rental car and a private entrance for easy, genuinely quiet stays.

3 BR · 2 BASleeps 6

$182per night · est.

Explore listing
Gold Pearl Villa, Fortune Bay · Freeport, Grand Bahama
Private boat dock

Fortune Bay · Grand Bahama

Gold Pearl Villa

A four-bedroom luxury villa on a private Freeport canal, with an 80-foot dock, a saltwater pool, and individual guest suites for genuinely private stays.

4 BR · 4.5 BASleeps 8

$1162per night · est.

Explore listing

Prefer to browse by island first?

Free download

Get the free Bahamas Rental Checklist

The 30-point list we run before booking any rental — scams to dodge, questions to ask hosts, and the fees that catch people out.

No spam. One email with the checklist, then only the occasional new-island guide.